Classical Spin

Rantings and ravings on politics, philosophy, and things that fall into the ether of 'none of the above'.

Tuesday, October 11, 2005

Why am I still thinking about this?

I can't seem to make myself let go of the Air Force Academy thing. Part of a comment from my last post on it:
the reason they have that 'odd looking chapel' and so on stuff is because of the part of the constitution that says "or prohibiting the free exercise thereof" (religion)... because of the nature of the academies and the military in general, not having an outlet for religious practice ON the base would limit people from practicing it, because many time duty and other restrictions keeps them on base
that's why that's there...

~air force academy grad

At first glance, this is a completely sound argument. I'm well aware that there are huge restrictions, both in terms of military responsibilities/privilages and the number of hours in a day, that could quite easily restrict the cadets and staff from being able to go to religious services off-campus. Fair enough: I'll be the first to say that everyone has a right to whatever manner of religious worship they want.

But. (You knew there was a 'but' coming, didn't you?) But the problem is that being in the military is a choice. We have an entirely volunteer military, and I personally wouldn't want it any other way. Attending the Academy, joining the Army, whatever - it's all entirely voluntary. I know for a fact that not only are freshman at the Academy provided with ample opportunities to leave the Academy, but one could even say that they are encouraged to do so, through means such as "basic training". No one is forcing them to be there, and none of the staff have been forced to be their either. It's completely voluntary.

And, as everyone is well aware, when you join the military you take the good with the bad. On the one hand, you're pretty much assured a job and someplace to live. On the other hand, that might be "trying to convince Iraqis that you don't deserve to die" and "A tent on the outskirts of Baghdad". It's a package deal: if you want to be in the military, you take the good and the bad together. That's just how life works - choices, and constantly needing to decide if Perk A is worth Drawback B.

I'm not convinced that the issue of religion at the Academy is in any way different from the above example. You want to go to a well-regarded tech school, be guarenteed on-campus housing, get a $30k/year education completely free at taxpayer expense - indeed, even get paid for getting that education - and so on? Great. You need to meet these admissions criteria, take an oath, wear a uniform, go through boot camp, and so on. I don't see 'if you want to sit in church, go off federal ground to do so' to be too ridiculous. If you don't have enough time to do so or can't get off campus - so be it. I'm not saying that they should ban, say, having a bible in your room, or a rosary, or anything like that. Practice religion on your own: fine. Practice religion at the expense of taxpayers: Not fine.

Anyway, if the military can ban people from revealing their sexuality if it's anything other than "strictly hetero", then I say they can tell them to take their church off government property.

1 Comments:

At 16:40, Anonymous Anonymous said...

When you take the oath of office upon coming to the academy and after graduating from the academy, you swear to "support and defend the Constitution of the United States, against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same"... this is the same constitution that insists "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof"... as there is nothing in the Oath of Office that would preclude "prohibited the free exercise thereof", your quid pro quo example is off.
Also, chaplains work for military families as well. A military member might be stationed in, Germany. I'm not sure, but I doubt there are many synagogues in Germany... BUT, the family of the military member would be given the opportunity to express their religious freedom on base with the help of a military chaplain. Military chaplains also cater to religions other than their own. While at the academy, it was a protestant chaplain who helped all members of my squadron through a very trying time, even though not all members were protestant. They are councilors and pillars of moral support. Also, if you really need to talk to someone, they are THE ONLY people in the entire military with whom you can have complete legal confidentiality should you need it.
ok, that was my rant :-)

 

Post a Comment

<< Home